A disturbing video has raised concerns about horse welfare and prompted renewed efforts for animal protection after a carriage horse collapsed in Central Park, New York.
A pedicab driver captured the painful scenes of a horse stumbling onto a roadway, and struggling to get back up before finally collapsing in Central park on a Saturday afternoon.
The 12-year-old horse named Aisha had reportedly completed her first ride of the day and was waiting for her next one inside the park around 7th Avenue when her hind legs suddenly gave way and she staggered forward before falling to the ground.
DISTURBING.— julie marie cappiello Ⓥ (@jmcappiello) February 29, 2020
This carriage horse from Clinton Park Stables is seen stumbling and unable to straighten their back legs in Central Park earlier today.
After years of doing nothing for carriage horses, will @NYCCouncil finally protect them? cc: @CoreyinNYC pic.twitter.com/EzSgvxoCkb
“The horse showed sudden signs of distress around 12:30 pm on Saturday after doing a single ride and then waiting for approximately an hour and a half at the 7th Ave carriage stand,” said a spokesperson for the Historic Horse-Drawn Carriages of Central Park.
“The vet and our emergency horse trailer were called immediately, and the horse unhitched and unharnessed.
“She progressively and rapidly weakened in her hind end and unexpectedly collapsed.
“The trailer arrived within 10 minutes of the call and, since the horse could not stand, she was slid into the trailer, following large animal rescue protocols, and returned to her stable on 52nd St.”
‘Carriage horses are in a crisis’
The unfortunate incident has sparked a row with demonstrators and campaigners urging the law to end the cruel practices of the carriage industry.
A group of New Yorkers for Clean, Livable, and Safe Streets (NYCLASS) demonstrators lined up at Central Park for an ‘emergency rally’ on Sunday.
Edita Birnkrant, executive director of NYCLASS said: “Instead of calling a qualified vet, to help this horse, several carriage drivers tied him up with ropes, shoved, pulled him into a trailer and they took him back to the stable.
“This video is just the latest disturbing piece of evidence we’ve seen showing how poorly these horses are treated and what they go through on these busy city streets,” added Birnkrant in a statement.
“New York City’s carriage horses are in a crisis. They are overworked, under cared for, and put in dangerous situations every day with no accountability when things like this happen.
“This is an industry out of control. That’s why we are calling on all the authorities who have the ability to fully, immediately shut down this abusive industry. We need a third-party investigation. It cannot be the very city agencies that are so inept to allow this abuse.”
However, the carriage association insisted that it followed large-animal rescue protocols and a veterinarian and an emergency horse trailer were on call to take care of the fallen horse.
The group instead accused the activists of “exploiting this tragedy to further their anti-horse agenda during our time of grief and shock.”
According to the group, Aisha seemed to suffer a cardiac arrest and this could happen to any animal, anywhere and anytime.
“Medical emergencies can happen to the healthiest horses, receiving the best, highly-regulated care,” the association said in a statement.
Christina Hansen, a spokesperson for the NYC Carriage Industry added that after assessing the situation, the veterinarian advised euthanizing Aisha as her condition deteriorated further.
“Her regular vet was able to begin assessment and treatment within an hour,” said Hansen.
“Unfortunately, she was never able to stand… Her owner, in consultation with the vet, made the difficult but humane decision to put her to sleep.”
The incident has also caught the attention of several authorities. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio tweeted the video was ‘painful’ and the “NYPD’s Animal Cruelty Investigation Squad” would investigate the incident further.
His tweet drew several comments from followers urging him to ban the cruel practice.
“Seriously. Just ban them already. Tourists will still come to NYC & they’ll still visit Central Park without carriages. Let them ride the carousel instead,” wrote a user.
“They should be banned. This is animal abuse!!! Animals used as rides and tourist attractions are not what’s best for animals. It’s time to do the humane thing and stop using animals this way for our entertainment,” added another.
The video of a horse collapsing and dying in Central Park yesterday is painful and says so much about a persistent problem.— Mayor Bill de Blasio (@NYCMayor) March 1, 2020
We’ve made real progress in animal welfare but we must go further. The NYPD’s Animal Cruelty Investigation Squad is on the case and WILL get answers.
Council Speaker Corey Johnson also posted the video on Twitter calling for immediate investigations.
There should be an immediate investigation into what happened to this horse and the cause of death.— Corey Johnson (@CoreyinNYC) March 1, 2020
This video is painful to watch and the public deserves answers. https://t.co/9NKvqWJgv8
Share this story to reveal the pitiful plight of carriage horses and if you want the industry to be banned.
Vegan culture, food, beauty & more
- Mohsina Dodhiya
- 30th July 2021
“Hopeful[ly] this historic step can spur a wave of legislation to protect all life on Earth while we still have time.” The City Council of Berkeley has passed a resolution to cut the city’s spending on animal-based products like meats and dairy by 50% by 2024. Under the new resolution, city-supplied places such as summer …
- Mohsina Dodhiya
- 27th July 2021
The Oxford study found a strong association between red and processed meat consumption and increased heart disease risk. Red and processed meat increase the risk of heart disease by nearly one-fifth, a new study has found. The study published in the journal Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition is one of the largest systematic …
All the quizzes you love to binge!
- Marlon Farrugia
- 10th January 2020
How much vegan knowledge do you have stored away? Do you have to Google your way through a shopping trip, or do you have all the bad E-numbers memorised? Find out now with this quiz. Marlon Farrugia Marlon Farrugia is a freelance writer from Brighton. He has been a dedicated vegan for many years, and …
- Marlon Farrugia
- 13th October 2019
Spook Season approaches. There will be ghosts, goblins, ghouls, and glucose. You need a costume, and you want to it to show off your personality, which means VEGAN. But what to choose? Take our quiz to find out your perfect outfit. Marlon Farrugia Marlon Farrugia is a freelance writer from Brighton. He has been a …
- Marlon Farrugia
- 26th September 2019
“If you were a vegetable, what kind would you be?” A question that has tormented humanity throughout the ages – until now. Read: QUIZ: If you score 19/20 on THIS quiz, you’re a Vegan God Marlon Farrugia Marlon Farrugia is a freelance writer from Brighton. He has been a dedicated vegan for many years, and …